Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
Welcome to the Official Del Amitri Bulletin Board!
 
If you've lost your password, click on "login" and then "forgot password."


Pages: 1 2 
Some Other Sucker's Parade (Read 24761 times)
Sebastiaan
Empty
*
Offline


I Love Del Amitri!

Posts: 2
UK
Gender: male
Some Other Sucker's Parade
03/18/08 at 09:48:01
 
From: [url]www.ridinghood.squarespace.com[/url]

After their 1989 break-through ‘Nothing Ever Happens’ Del Amitri set about unassumingly building a career. Each successive album opened up their music to a moderately wider audience, culminating in an impressive US Top 10 chart position for ‘Roll To Me’, achieved seemingly without effort in 1995, a time when British Bands found it notoriously hard to gain a foothold in that territory.

Then, in 1997 they released the album ‘Some Other Sucker’s Parade’ and… committed career suicide.

However, Some Other Sucker’s Parade’ (SOSP) is Del Amitri’s finest album to date and the only truly great album they ever made.

Their previous long players, while undeniably accomplished, were generally rather uneven affairs, especially compared to SOSP. They contained admittedly many highlights, but seemed strained, even contrived as a whole, as if the matter had been given just too much thought.

This strain can be attributed to self-consciousness, specifically: a constant awareness of their own extreme idiosyncrasy: they never managed to lose sight of the fact that they were attempting to do something extraordinary. I mean, seriously: how did a Scottish country rock band manage to score even one hit in the Nineties anyway, let alone a whole handful?

The continued success of Radiohead in particular (their polar opposites) must have been a constant source of worry for them. How did Radiohead, as well as Oasis and Blur, manage to have more successful careers with songs not half as good, they must have asked themselves. What are we overlooking? – Rather than blocking out their surroundings and creating music honestly, Del Amitri seemed sometimes too concerned with ensuring the wool remain pulled over the press and public’s eyes. Who can blame them?

The success of ‘Roll To Me’ must have come as a great relief. Perhaps they set to work on SOSP with renewed confidence in the validity of their endeavour. The album is almost a point for point refutation of the Radiohead ethos, rather than the work of a good band, capable of writing good songs, trying desperately to poach fans from more successful contemporaries.

Indeed, while they show themselves masters of everything at which Radiohead are hopelessly inept (writing, arranging and performing songs,) they demonstratively show disdain for everything at which Radiohead excel. What to make of that cover, for starters: Justin and Iain look like a pair of homeless drunks. Iain in particular pushes hobo chic onto a whole new level. (As the Beach Boys also discovered to their mortification when they had themselves photographed feeding goats on the cover of ‘Pet Sounds’, the public does not habitually recognise masterpieces by their lack of glamour.) Besides this, the album sounds as if it was recorded live using only one microphone. It always makes me laugh to see a mixing engineer in the credit list. What did he do: push up the fader?

On SOSP, Del Amitri were finally playing to their strengths. They had reached the stage where they could comfortably write and perform 14 songs of similar scope and magnitude. And while there is nothing on SOSP so sublime as ‘Roll To Me’ (surely: the last ever great pop song) there is among the 14 songs not a single dud.

Justin inhabits throughout a role with which he is comfortable. He was, during their successful period, certainly the photogenic type, but had no real taste for cultivating his personality into marketable proportions, preferring instead to act onstage and in videos like an awkward goofball, charming, but ultimately too aloof for the masses. The unnerving sense, marring previous albums, that he is forcing himself to keep one eye on the kids and making the odd token concession is absent from SOSP, the lyrics expressing at all times only a mature and melancholy Romantic resignation.

Iain Harvie makes no attempts to be a cutting edge guitar hero (something which he had tried with varying degrees of success on the previous album ‘Twisted’,) and instead remains stunningly tasteful and appropriate for the duration. The whole thing just sounds…well: relaxed.

Perhaps they were just too tired to continue competing with the likes of Radiohead, and decided simply to make a good record, without regard for fashion or trend. If the success of ‘Roll To Me’ is anything to go by, they must have reasoned, we might get lucky. They had not taken into account the measureless spite and bile that publications such as the execrable NME can muster for rock bands that achieve success without their sanction and for anything that can all too easily be recognised as a Radiohead anti-dote. When Del Amitri performed the first single from SOSP, ‘Not Where It’s At’, on TOTP, their performance involved jumping around and laughing.

Perhaps SOSP was from the start conceived as a suicide attempt. Perhaps the very title ‘Some Other Sucker’s Parade’ represented an admission of defeat, calling time on a career that had largely run its course anyway, and abandoning the field to some other sucker, but leaving future Radiohead clones with one last untouchable blueprint for excellence, a magnificent last hurrah for a dying tendency. For make no mistake: when ‘Some Other Sucker’s Parade’ flopped, what essentially failed to connect with an audience was - Britain's last great songwriter.

I don’t have my finger on
The pulse of my generation
I just got my hand on my heart
Know no better location
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
susi
Low Friends In High Places (250+)
****
Offline


I love the Dels!

Posts: 427
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #1 - 03/18/08 at 11:19:54
 
first I wanted to disagree - but then : Britain's last great songwriter. damn!

love this interesting article, it's funny and tragic. both
thanks sebastian
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Tintagel
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


lousy for del

Posts: 874
West coast of Canada
Gender: female
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #2 - 03/18/08 at 13:31:24
 
Lovely, brought a tear and a grin.

As this is also my fav album I concur.
Back to top
 

maybe I'll be always laughing
 
IP Logged
 
David
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Wilfully wobbling through
life

Posts: 996
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #3 - 03/18/08 at 14:09:19
 
Whether you think it's accurate or not, it's a plainly bitchy article, especially regarding his opinion of Radiohead, which seems to be more the source of his ire than his love of SOSP.

Disliking another band is a different issue to accusing them of being unable to write, arrange or perform songs.  It's pretty clear that Radiohead are still around for a reason, and it's not that they were ever fashionable (weird, intellectual, awkward song structures, scattershot lyrics - yes, how mainstream).  They write incredible music and have taken their fans with them as they've experimented.  Justin crappity smacks around for years between records and then seems pissed off that people don't automatically accept it.

There can be no doubt that The Bends is better than any album the Dels ever did - OK Computer similarly thrashed any Dels record for a very simple reason: quality control.  If there wasn't so much shite on each Dels record (excepting CE, but the production on that is so corny that it nearly drowns the material on occasion), they'd stand up better. 

The writer makes a mistake that Iain Harvie was trying to be cutting edge on Twisted - as if playing retro rock riffs and Stones-esque solos was ever cutting edge - that had been going on for years already.  Making a tough record with elements of the Stooges about it isn't really cutting edge, and the automatic drop into pub-rock on the rest of the album diminished his point anyway.

His whole point seems to be that, by virtue of being utterly conventional, the Dels were somehow totally against the grain of the times - which is utter shite.  There was a massive resurgence in song-based music at the time, led by Radiohead and Oasis, amongst others.

And Justin as Britain's last Great songwriter?

Jarvis Cocker, Thom Yorke, Imogen Heap, PJ Harvey all immediately spring to mind.

What a crock of shit.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
ChrissieA
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Can't imagine life without
Del Amitri in it!

Posts: 2214
Colchester, England
Gender: female
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #4 - 03/18/08 at 14:42:32
 
Sebastiaan - if you wrote this then I apologise, but I agree with David on this one.

I really dislike the constant comparison with Radiohead, the turgid writing and comments like ‘Roll To Me’ (surely: the last ever great pop song).  Eh!?

SOSP 'aint one of my favourites especially but I think 'career suicide' is a bit harsh.  I'm too tired to pick out other bits I don't like.

Back to top
 

I'm a woman with nothing to do....
 
IP Logged
 
Tintagel
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


lousy for del

Posts: 874
West coast of Canada
Gender: female
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #5 - 03/18/08 at 17:42:43
 
But do you disagree David?

(sorry - it just slipped out - I knew Joe would want to say it if he was here)
Back to top
 

maybe I'll be always laughing
 
IP Logged
 
susi
Low Friends In High Places (250+)
****
Offline


I love the Dels!

Posts: 427
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #6 - 03/19/08 at 01:47:14
 
yeah it is a bitchy article and radiohead isn't the writers favorite band, that's pretty obvious.
SOSP isn't my favorite record, and when it comes to Great songwriters he did forget Lloyd Cole too -
but it is somehow well written.I laughed and cried.Wink

a lot of disagreement from my side too - if you want to look at it in a "serious" way. Smiley
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
susi
Low Friends In High Places (250+)
****
Offline


I love the Dels!

Posts: 427
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #7 - 03/19/08 at 01:49:05
 
.. but there is some truth in it, david!

I hope you are not another version of Joe.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Johnny Too Bad
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Look at ma boaby!

Posts: 623
UK
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #8 - 03/19/08 at 02:24:14
 
All down to taste of course, but I utterly despise Radiohead (and all the subsequent copyists) and reckon Justin could produce better music than Thom Yorke with the very wind from his arse.

Twisted is my least favourite of the "Big 4" Del albums for many of the reasons David outlines, and I can't really choose between SOSP and CE for my top del album. They both have 12 great tracks on them (SOSP is, IMHO, two tracks too long) and I actually like the production on both equally. Crisp, clean and radio friendly on CE, Street Legal-stylee electric soup on SOSP

Though Waking Hours is their best produced album, it has a couple of fairly lame songs that haven't stood the test of time.
Back to top
 

And I know their mothers' ages and I know all the stories so well&&And I know I'll see their faeces in Hull.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Sebastiaan
Empty
*
Offline


I Love Del Amitri!

Posts: 2
UK
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #9 - 03/19/08 at 16:11:30
 
Thanks, guys, for your responses. It was not my intention to come across as bitchy, sorry; I merely tried to write something that, while making some points that have struck me about the group over the years, would capture the Del Amitri spirit. I am Dutch and have a tendency to pose things too sharply. I am delighted that some of you (Susi and Tintagel) got a sense at least of the effect I was trying (perhaps not very successfully) to achieve. A tear and a grin, indeed: that is the Del Amitri world-view. That is why I love them. Forever.

Sebastiaan.

www.ridinghood.squarespace.com
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
David
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Wilfully wobbling through
life

Posts: 996
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #10 - 03/20/08 at 02:25:09
 
susi wrote on 03/19/08 at 01:49:05:
.. but there is some truth in it, david!

I hope you are not another version of Joe.


Not sure how there could be any comparison with Joe: I disagreed with something and explained why.  i didn't attack anyone's post, just made clear that it's hardly a well-balanced argument.

If SOSP failed, it was because the ship had sailed for the Dels, not because of some career suicide.  The album art looked as utterly throwaway as could be imagined.  Two blokes in a room: that doesn't stand for honesty, it stands for a lack of inspiration - something that's rife throughout the album.

I'm all for reading articles with interesting viewpoints, but this one is more than a little off-base.  Disagreeing with it hardly makes me a curmudgeon - just honest and with a more neutral perspective it seems.

Also, I didn't include Lloyd Cole because I think he predates Waking Hours (my count as the Dels true beginning) - if we're going outside of my boundaries then there's not much competition to be had with Elvis Costello, who is simply better than any other living British songwriter today.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
David
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Wilfully wobbling through
life

Posts: 996
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #11 - 03/20/08 at 02:31:22
 
Sebastiaan wrote on 03/19/08 at 16:11:30:
Thanks, guys, for your responses. It was not my intention to come across as bitchy, sorry; I merely tried to write something that, while making some points that have struck me about the group over the years, would capture the Del Amitri spirit. I am Dutch and have a tendency to pose things too sharply. I am delighted that some of you (Susi and Tintagel) got a sense at least of the effect I was trying (perhaps not very successfully) to achieve. A tear and a grin, indeed: that is the Del Amitri world-view. That is why I love them. Forever.

Sebastiaan.

www.ridinghood.squarespace.com


I don't think the article was badly-written, but it came across more that you think Radiohead are shit rather than the Dels are great.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
susi
Low Friends In High Places (250+)
****
Offline


I love the Dels!

Posts: 427
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #12 - 03/20/08 at 06:39:37
 
BUT SEBASTIAN:

Justin and Iain look like a pair of homeless drunks.

this is a LIE, isn't it?


David, you're not quite wrong .
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
the last to know
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


"Oh bollicking damn &
jumbo buggers!"

Posts: 1309
a mountain backwater in NC
Gender: female
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #13 - 03/20/08 at 08:48:21
 
No, they do look like derelicts on the cover of SOSP.  Certainly as though they couldn't be bothered to support their own work.
Back to top
 

"People are rarely strange and mostly dull but sometimes they worm away at you like a fascinating doubt."
 
IP Logged
 
Johnny Too Bad
Funny Way To Win (500+)
*****
Offline


Look at ma boaby!

Posts: 623
UK
Gender: male
Re: Some Other Sucker's Parade
Reply #14 - 03/20/08 at 08:56:10
 
I reckon the general horribleness of Del Amitri's album covers (CE aside) have always been pre-emptive means of explaining away subsequent poor sales.  It was why it was good to see the solo album packaged so nicely.
Back to top
 

And I know their mothers' ages and I know all the stories so well&&And I know I'll see their faeces in Hull.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
(Moderator: webmaster)